I'll start this post off by saying once again how much I appreciate the open atmosphere in the classroom, facilitated by Noura and contributed to by all of the students. I love it and value it. I thought that the discussion today was interesting, but also somewhat superficial (maybe not the correct word). This was potentially because of our collective, relatively limited knowledge regarding ancient history, or potentially because we all seem to view "true history" in a similar regard (we've all seemed to agree that whatever "really" happened doesn't really matter because people believe what they believe is true and not much can be done to change that). Today seemed to me to be more of a summary, where we all pointed out different parts about each section that stood out to us. While I do think that there is value to that, I know that in the future I will make a conscious effort to come up with questions (and raise them in class) that push me to think more deeply about the material that we read, even if it is predominantly facts….upon facts upon facts. This will allow us to not only quickly review the sometimes difficult material that we read, but also explore the implications of what we've just learned in Armstrong's text and others.
I think it's very interesting that so far we have all had similar opinions regarding the issues of truth, history, respect, discussion/debate, the role that religion plays/should play in narratives & other opinions. This, to me, does not hint that we all think the same way or that we all view this topic through the same lens, but simply that we are all logical, thoughtful people who understand and respect the complexity of the thoughts and opinions formed around this and all other contentious issues (this is another reason why I feel so comfortable in class).
Looking forward to next week, I expect we will be benefitting immensely from having read these history-intensive chapters as we move on to more modern history. It is incredibly important to have a strong foundation of historical knowledge before going on to analyze current events.
Can't wait to see you guys tomorrow!
Sophie and Ari,
ReplyDeleteI think a lot of what we have covered in class thus far has been mostly non-controversial. As the course progresses we get to hear from perspectives from differing sides I think arguments will naturally occur. I look forward to hearing others opinions expressed as well as expressing mine.
Hello Sophie,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your post. I appreciate your willingness to raise difficult questions and your determination to do so. I agree with Daniel's comment above. I think that when topics become more and more personal, comments are bound to as well. I hope that we will be able to maintain an atmosphere of mutual respect and look forward to discussing these topics as a class!
I too agree with Daniel on this one. It does seem that everything we've discussed thus far has been neutral, conversation-based topics and ideas. I think that the disagreements and more intense conversation are to come and will make for a more well-rounded understanding upon completing the class!
ReplyDeleteYou are all right--we're definitely still in the beginning stages of the class, and I, like you four, am excited to delve into more difficult material. Thank you guys so much for reading and commenting!
ReplyDelete